Environmental Hazards Health Jharkhand

In the line of fire

The Jharia mines in Jharkhand's Dhanbad district produce the best quality coking coal in India. However, the area, mostly inhabited by tribals, has been smouldering with underground mine fires for several decades now. Kalpana Pradhan reports on the health impacts.

The 80,000-odd people living in the coal belt of Jharia in Jharkhand’s Dhanbad district breathe fire - quite literally. The Jharia mines produce the best quality coking coal (used in blast furnaces) in India. However, the area, mostly inhabited by tribals, has been smouldering with underground mine fires for several decades now. The fires emit huge quantities of carbon monoxide, carbon dioxide, sulphur dioxide and methane, leading to air pollution, breathing problems and skin diseases.

“Our house is always very hot and smoke continuously billows out from under the floor,” says Aduri Devi, in her 70s, of Nadiper Basti. For the past five years, she and her family of seven have been living under a tree outside their basti (settlement). “We cannot inhale the gas that the coal mines emit,” she says, coughing as the foul smelling emissions enter her nostrils

Mining in Jharia started in 1894. In 1916, the first coal mine fire was detected. In 1971, when it was nationalised, Bharat Coking Coal Limited (BCCL), the chief coke-producing company in the region, adopted opencast and slaughter mining methods - where only top-of-the-mine coal is extracted. This involves digging massive pits to procure coal, and is cheap and efficient. This causes fires in the abandoned mines, which are exposed to the atmosphere and are susceptible to spontaneous combustion. These fires cost the company 37 million tonnes of coking coal through fires and also caused pollution levels to soar.

The local administration and BCCL - which operates 76 mines in India; 74 of these are in Jharia - have declared Jharia a danger zone, and have asked residents to leave the area. So far, 40 bastis in the collieries are in the process of being evacuated. Under a pilot project to resettle the people, BCCL, in collaboration with the state government, has spent Rs.610 million to construct houses for 9,000 families in Jharia. The Union government has also sanctioned Rs.75 million for the rehabilitation of the 80,000 families threatened by mine fires and subsidence or caving in of earth - caused due to the weakening of the soil due to the increase in the level of sulphuric acid - in the coalfield area. (1 crore = 10 million)

The people, though, refuse to leave. “Jharia is the land of our ancestors. It is difficult for us to move to another place. BCCL has been promising us jobs for over 20 years, but no one from Jharia has been employed yet. How can we trust these same people to provide us homes outside Jharia?” asks Prakash Narayan Bagchi, secretary, Jharia Bachao Samiti, a committee formed by the people of Jharia to fight against the eviction orders. “For over two decades, the state government has been promising us land. Their actual aim is to evict people from their own land, and extract even greater amounts of coal from the region,” says Gour Kumbhakar, now in his 60s, a resident of Nadiper Basti area.

H Chakravarty, superintendent, engineering cell of environment department, BCCL, attempts to clear the air: “We are asking them to move due to the health hazards that the region presents, and are also running awareness camps on this. During the camps we show films on coal fires and the hazards of living near them. We also hold meeting on holidays and evenings to spread to inform the people.” He says that the affected are enquiring about rehabilitation schemes after attending the camps.

In 1972, there were about 70 active fires over an area of 17 square kilometres in Jharia. In spite of numerous plans to control them, so far only 10 fires have been controlled through techniques like ‘blanketing’, ‘nitrogen flushing’ and ‘stowing’. “Controlling coal fires is a costly and time-consuming process because it is difficult to say how the fire is spreading under the mines,” he explains.

Meanwhile, people attempt to survive in the fire zone. Guriya, 9, Kumara basti has been suffering from high fever for the last three months. “When she discontinues her medicine, she falls sick again,” says Swiju Devi, 23, her mother. A few months back, Guriya suffered from chronic breathing problems. Life is equally hellish in neighbouring bastis like Lodhna and Kumara.

“Most of my patients suffer from tuberculosis, chronic lung disease, bronchial asthma and pneumoconiosis. About 80 to 85 per cent of them are suffering from breathing difficulties,” says Dr Rajiv Agarwaal, a local doctor. Earlier, he says, the majority of his patients were in the 30-35 age group. Now they are between 20 to 25 years of age. “Poisonous emissions from the blazing coal mines are getting mixed with the residents’ haemoglobin,” he feels.

Mira, 27, who stays at the old Jharia station basti, has already lost two children to malnutrition. Now into the third month of pregnancy, she suffers from tuberculosis and breathing problems. “Even though I eat adequately and have medicines, the doctor says I am anaemic. My husband is a rickshaw puller, so this is all I can afford,” she says, adding, “I think am going to die, like my mother and my friend, of tuberculosis.”

In an area dotted with hospitals for BCCL employees, the district administration proclaims that it has set up primary health centres near the collieries to provide free treatment to the coal mine-affected population. However, residents say these centres do not have enough medicines, and the people are forced to go to expensive private doctors for treatment. If they do not have money for the doctor, they just ask the pharmacist to prescribe medicines.

“We have always stocked tuberculosis and asthma medicines. But, in the last five years, the demand for these medicines has increased. Sometimes, people approach us for treatment and we know that if we do not give them medicines, they will die. Sometimes we ask doctors to help them with their treatment,” says Swaroop Mondol of Ranchi Medical Store, which set up shop about 20 years ago.

BCCL authorities claim that in the last 16 years, they have taken various pollution control measures. One of these is converting 3,374 hectares of degraded land into a green belt. “Since 1980, we have been working in these areas, planting 25 trees like teak, acacia and neem in the affected areas,” says Chakraborty. Areas such as Jogta, Gopalichak, Sandra Bansjhora, where coal fires had been blazing since the early 1960s, are now green. Explaining that putting out fires is also a priority, he says that the best technique is digging out the fire from the fire zone and then blanketing it with sand and soil to cut off the oxygen.

Meanwhile, the state government has set up a Jharia Rehabilitation and Development Authority to resettle affected families. It is now waiting for the Union cabinet to give the go-ahead for implementation of the resettlement plans. But all these efforts will come to naught unless the government and BCCL can convince the residents of Jharia that they must step off the fire zone. The authorities must then ensure that their grandiose plans are not another link in a long history of betrayals. (Women’s Feature Service)

Filed under

Environmental Hazards Health Mining Relief Jharkhand

Cite this article

Kalpana Pradhan (2006) ‘In the line of fire’, India Together, 13 November 2006. https://indiatogether.org/mining-health/

2 reader responses

Add a response

An editor reads every response before it appears. Links are not published, and no email address is asked for or stored.

  1. R.Sudhakar · 18 November 2006

    While it is stated that the first fire started in 1916, when the entire operations were in private hands, the author strangely states or implies that the present situation is because of the BCCL (which came into existence only in 1971) adopting 'slaughter mining' and open-cast mining methods. She obviously has not bothered to find out as to why the fires(s) got started in the first place. It is known to the entire Jharia mining community( not the present generation though) that during the first world war (1914 – 18) the then British rulers looked the other way, if not actively encouraging, the mine operators to adopt ‘slaughter mining’ to increase the coal production to meet their demands for the war effort , This was the main cause for the mine fires. Another factor which had contributed was the practice of brewing illicit liquor in the unguarded mine-openings, old quarries and goafs (subsidence areas of broken ground after extraction of coal in underground mines). It may be noted that a very popular refrain of the protagonists of nationalization of coal mines was that the private coal mine owners habitually adopted unscientific slaughter mining . A close examination may reveal the amount of 'slaughter mining' that BBCL has indulged in. It may be recalled Sanjay Gandhi had made a statement that nationalisation of the coal mines was a great blunder. While no brief need be held for the BCCL which has an abominable record of flouting standard practices of mining and mine management one need not blame it for the fires that have been raging uncontrolled for over fifty years. If anything it should be commended for the (half hearted ?)efforts it has made . Relocation of Jharia township and rehabilitation of its population is inevitable. Putting it off is a near impossibility and any efforts could only be a wasteful expenditure. May be the advance of the fire further could be retarded for a while to gain time to put through the programme of relocation of the township. And it is not a case of only ‘tribal people’ that are involved. Jharia town has been the abode of many multi- millionaires with opulent living quarters. It is likely they may be the force behind the Jharia Bachao movement. This aspect needs the close attention of journalists like Ms Pradhan keeping in view the likely demand in future for compensation that may be put forward by these rich persons And sooner the programme of rehabilitation of the poorer section of the population is implemented and some way is found to deal effectively with legal hurdles that may crop up is put through the better for initiating the plans for recovery of the underlying valuable coking coal reserves before they are all consumed by the advancing fire(s).

  2. shivendre kumar · 18 September 2007

    although everyone knows that the fire in the jharia coal belt started way back in 1916 but after BCCL took over the mining area nothing much has been done to control or stop the fire.BCCL got crores n crores of rupees from the world bank.Has anybody asked what exactly has been done with that money.Although the officials will give the action taken report on the same but in reality the money has gone in the pockets of corrupt officials and the politians.There was a major sand transportation scandal where in insufficient quantities of sand was stowed in the underground ines after exatraction of coal was done.None of the officials have been held responsible for the scandal.The fact is the Jharia fires can be controlled if there is a sincere effort to do so.but honestly the officials and the politians dont want the fires to be contained for their own selfish interests.And now to make the matters worse rasing contracts have been given to private contractors who wolud like the Jharia coal field to be evacuated at the earliest so that they can excavate the coal underneath.jharia fire can be controlled provided there is a WILL