Human Rights Society West Bengal
Lalgarh: Deprived of a peace of life
Not many trace their way back to the human tragedy that has given rise to the culture of violence that marks Lalgarh today. The women do not appear scared of any police reaction in response to their protests. Soma Mitra has more.
Lalgarh (WFS) - Once a decrepit block of West Bengal, Lalgarh in West Midnapore district has turned into a battlefield. Over the last few months, hundreds of women have taken to the streets shouting slogans as they march in processions of protest.
Why has this happened? Why have ordinary women found it necessary to pick up arms? At one level, Lalgarh is a turf war between the Communist Party India (Marxist), the People’s Committee Against Police Atrocities (PCPA) and the insurgent Maoists. At another, it is also about a troubled community fighting for survival and the simple necessities of life, such as potable water and education for their children.

“We are deprived of clean drinking water, we are deprived of proper schools and, frankly speaking, the government has done nothing for us. We have no other way but to revolt against the government,” says Shashi Murmu, 28, of Mulapara village. Her mother, Tara, 51, who has also taken up arms, adds, “For a long while, we have been deprived of everything. We have decided that from now we will fight the government.” There are about 600 families at Mulapara in the Shalboni block of East Midnapore district where the Jindal Special Economic Zone (SEZ) is slated to come up. And almost all the families there highlight the same woes as Shashi and Tara.
Surprisingly, the women do not appear scared of any police reaction that their protests may invite. Police atrocity is nothing new for the villagers of these areas, who state that the police indiscriminately pick up villagers whenever there is a Maoist attack. In fact, the men who flee from the villages as soon as combined operations are announced and the women are left to face the wrath of the security forces. While the police claim that they do not generally pick up women for interrogation, people here have no recourse should they find themselves treated harshly and unjustly. They don’t have access to legal support, for instance.
Police atrocity is nothing new for the villagers of these areas, who say that the police indiscriminately pick up villagers whenever there is a Maoist attack.
Government agencies were shaken once images of women with arms began flooding the media recently. Some weeks ago, the state government decided to send a six-member delegation to assess the actual situation on the ground. The experience of this delegation was a major eye-opener. “I was shocked to see many are yet to get ration cards. People who should rightly have been enlisted as Below the Poverty Line (BPL) are listed as Above Poverty Line (APL),” R D Meena, Secretary, Backward Classes Welfare, a delegate, is reported to have said.
Says Gouri Mahato of Domahani village, “The panchayat (village council) had assured my family of job cards under the National Rural Employment Guarantee Act (NREGA) scheme two years ago but that has not happened till date.” The NREGA provides a legal guarantee for 100 days of employment in every financial year to adult members of any rural household willing to do public work-related unskilled manual work for a statutory minimum wage.
Gouri’s family had five bighas (One bigha = 0.4 hectare) of land. But the family was forced to sell it off when her mother fell critically ill. The mother had to be taken to a Kolkata hospital for treatment as the Lalgarh health centre had no doctor on duty. So a job card means a great deal to Gouri’s family.
But, perhaps, Gouri, with no job card, is better off than Krishna Halder, who was issued a job card under NREGA two years ago. Even though Krishna was lucky enough to have the prized card, she had been issued only 14 days of work over the last two years. In a world where Krishna has to struggle to make ends meet for her family, her job card did not help. The daily struggle of life took its toll on the family. Krishna saw her son joining the PCPA and later on the Maoists before being taken into police custody.
Earlier these villages of West Midnapore district were the stronghold of the CPI(M). However, despite numerous promises and 33 years of Left rule, Lalgarh has yet to get a proper irrigation system and, in the absence of other necessary infrastructure, a large section of people here are still dependent on forest produce for their livelihood.
Take the case of Mohua Baskey, who goes into the forest every day at about five in the morning to collect ‘kendu pata’ (leaves used to roll tobacco to make indigenous cigarettes or ‘beedis’). Her 14-year-old daughter accompanies her on this daily two kilometre walk to the forest to supplement the family’s meagre income. The early morning toil and subsequent trip to the market only result in a meager Rs.15 to Rs.20 each day, for their family of four.
One can’t help wondering why Mohua is not getting her daughter educated. “There is a school in our locality. Besides, if I allow my daughter to go to school our income would be reduced by half,” says Mohua in the matter-of-fact manner. Ironically, every year the government sanctions millions for developmental projects in these backward areas of the state but the fund remains unutilised.
For instance, in the last financial year, Rs.5,000 million was sanctioned for the development of Paschimanchal (western range of the state) Development Affairs. This area is largely under the control of the Maoists and includes parts of West Midnapore, Bankura and Purulia. Only Rs 350 million of this amount has been used till date, according to the state’s budget statement of 2009-10.
The people of Lalgarh are heavily dependent on the Public Distribution System (PDS) for their daily nourishment and the government is required to make available PDS supplies of foodgrain at reasonable prices to consumers. But corruption has brought the local PDS system to the verge of collapse.
Take the case of the around 400 families in Gopalpur village, all of whom have ration cards. As these families are listed as BPL they are supposed to get 25 kilograms of rice at a rate of Rs.2.50 a month. However, villagers complain that ration dealers say they are entitled to only 10 kilograms of rice a month. Furthermore, it is said that the ration dealers have not returned to the villagers their ration cards. Hunger now has begun to stalk their lives: Mayarani Hul, 62, of village Amlasoli, recently lost her only son to malnutrition.
Not many perceive the human tragedy that has given rise to the culture of violence that marks Lalgarh today. Even women, who have never been in the forefront of such agitations, have now taken to violence simply to draw attention to the violation of their rights as citizens of this country. (Women’s Feature Service)
Filed under
Cite this article
Soma Mitra (2009) ‘Lalgarh: Deprived of a peace of life’, India Together, 13 August 2009. https://indiatogether.org/lalgarh-human-rights/
4 reader responses
Add a response
Jaipat Singh Jain · 18 August 2009
Thank you for the article. A point worth mentioning is that the residents of Lalgarh are tribals. Just as the Western invasion destroyed the "Red Indian" civilization, so did the "aryan" invasion destroy the tribals of India. The tribals are the original owners of the lands, including the forest areas. Ironically, when India became independent, the government's Forest Depts. were made to protect these forest areas for the benefit of the real owners, i.e. the tribals. Soon, the same Forest Dept and the State became the real owners, thereby depriving the tribals of their inherent rights. Now, these lands are being acquired forcibly in order to make special economic zones. What a journey!
Sachin · 18 August 2009
What is not mentioned is the sheer callousness and arrogance of the CPI(M) who have been in power in West Bengal for decades. The CPI(M) have milched the cow of poverty dry in the name of providing a pro-people government. Corruption has no boundaries in West Bengal and almost all the corruption is through the CPI(M) cadres. The killings that have taken place by the PCPA or the Maoists - were targetted at the corrupt mafia running all the social welfare schemes such as PDS, education, medicare etc. Those who have been singled out and killed were put to death by the people because they were corrupt, it is a coincidence that they were also invariably members of the CPI(M). It has been next to impossible to survive in West Bengal without being a supporter of the CPI(M).
Abhinandan Verma · 19 August 2009
After all this, we still think of 'developing' the nation! Government cannot leave some areas and move into others for the so called development. If development has to happen, it has to happen with each and every citizen of this country. These people deserve everything that we all deserve. Government has failed in managing affairs not only in Lalgarh but many other places as well (take Chhattisgarh for example). Government has been neglecting all this for the past 30 years! That is outrageous. And what we have with us these days is some areas which are exceptionally well managed and others like Lalgarh, Vechhapal which are totally mismanaged. This shows a total negligence on the part of the Government. Funds are not at all a problem, millions of people are paying taxes, government is generating revenues. Where is it all going? It is perfectly just on the part of people of Lalgarh to pick up arms and revolt. May be, that's the only way to open the eyes of sleeping government. The British Raj is still there for these people, even after 62 years of independence.
Prasun Bhattacharya · 4 September 2009
The article is biased. It coverts the maoist agenda of building free zone using arms and terror. Actually the reason behind the Lalgarh problem is political. It is not because of under development. If you see the 13 point demands raised by the PCPA (maoist), you will find no demand related to development. All are to remove the police force from the are, which will help the maoist to form free zone. Not only that, the lack of development is also because of maoist activities in the area.